The opening crawl of Revenge of the Sith is likely one of the most fascinating in all of Star Wars. Its speedy cry of conflict units a brand new establishment—one probably not seen on display at that time, solely lined in comics with additional exploration down to return with the likes of Clone Wars. But it surely’s the sentences that come after in that opening paragraph which are the actual salvo. A crumbling Republic, already? Heroes, on either side of a battle perpetually introduced to us as Good versus Unhealthy, Gentle versus Darkish? Evil in every single place?

In fact, there have been layers already to this we’d see as Revenge of the Sith progressed—the evil in every single place manifested as Palpatine’s machinations of either side of the Clone Struggle to result in that titular revenge. The heroes on either side would take future tales to essentially discover, troopers and leaders in a conflict that so few actually grasped how futile their heroism in the end was, as items on a chessboard. However the inherent complication that comes with pitting folks in opposition to one another, all of the causes they imagine in, and the alternatives they make in that battle, has at all times been a troublesome push and pull on the very coronary heart of what Star Wars is. The collection is a fantasy, crammed with resplendent heroes of a light-weight eternal, their foe an final evil: a maniacal, cackling specter on a quest to develop into an immortal embodiment of despair itself. That’s not difficult. There’s a facet to be on, and a facet to not be on.

And but, Star Wars can be in the end about folks, and individuals are fascinating and imperfect. Heroes could make dangerous choices, will be blinded by beliefs and make selections that spin wildly out of their meant outcomes. They’ll fall to darkness, so certain in what they’re doing as the fitting factor. Unhealthy folks can get away of unjust programs, or present some quantity of tragic justification for horrifying actions. A few of the those who have fallen furthest, will be pulled again into the sunshine and discover redemption. For a transparent reduce as Star Wars typically is—a fairy story in area, with clear definitions of who is correct and simply, and who’s mistaken and villainous—it’s typically at its easiest enjoying in its difficult shades, and chatting with the human imperfection on the core of its grand, sci-fi setting. It’s in that difficult shade—or reasonably, the potential for it, pushed by myriad different feelings—that The Acolyte thrusts us into this week with “Alternative,” the episode that lastly lays naked the thriller driving its heroes and villains alike: what actually occurred that evening 16 years in the past on Brendok?

“Alternative,” the penultimate episode of The Acolyte‘s debut season, is an enchanting sister episode to its daring flashbacks again in episode three, “Future”. If that episode performed with a Rashomon affect to offer us a singular, biased perspective on the occasions that noticed Mae and Osha break up aside and the Brendok witch coven burned in flame—trusting us to not have the complete image but, however to acknowledge that what was laid in entrance of us was an imperfect perspective—”Alternative” finds nice energy in not simply the context it gives those self same occasions, however a energy in broadening the views we see that context via. Now not confined to the naïve perspective of a kid craving to search out her personal method outdoors what’s requested of her, the tragedy that performs out on this quiet forest world casts mild and shadows throughout all of its concerned events. What had been as soon as clear savior figures within the Jedi develop into compromised folks in their very own methods, pushed and pulled by emotional circumstance, their perceived duties, and the inherent flaw of a galactic group whose larger image typically blinds what its members should be in a given second. What was as soon as the egocentric fury of a sister, turns into a selection impacted by the hurts and fears of a complete household. What was in a single flip a tragic accident, in one other turns into a collection of regrets and misunderstandings that explode into each other, bringing a dread inevitability with them.

As acquainted beats and scenes replay with this broadened context—continually reminding us because the viewers that these are all imperfect views of the occasions unfolding—”Alternative” doesn’t simply make the occasions of Mae and Osha’s childhoods clearer to us, it muddies these occasions in fascinatingly difficult methods. By the tip of the episode, now we have an understanding of what occurred on this one evening on Brendok: initially rebuffed however in the end compromised with, a quartet of Jedi examined two younger ladies from a coven of witches for his or her capability to wield the Drive. A kind of Jedi, a younger grasp named Sol, linked with the craving of a type of ladies, Osha, to go away her dwelling and develop into a Jedi reasonably than a witch—a connection that pulls him to make a determined case that it’s his and his fellow Jedi’s duties to liberate these two youngsters from their dwelling. Worry and judgment on either side results in anger and battle, as Jedi and witches alike activate one another in self protection, leaving many lifeless. Sol is left among the many ruins of a burning coven to make one closing selection: sacrifice one youngster to avoid wasting the one he has shaped attachment to. A selection amongst many selections of the evening that’s in the end lined up, to the surviving Osha and to the broader Jedi Order alike, leaving simply these 4 Jedi—Sol, Indara, her padawan Torbin, and the Wookiee Kelnacca—burdened by the reality for the subsequent 16 years. However it’s in these moments of selection, in these fears, these angers, these misjudgments by each the Jedi and the Brendok witches, that the episode sings, bringing a textural messiness to this ostensibly clarified understanding.

That in and of itself is an enchanting parallel to the sooner flashbacks we noticed in “Future”—that paradoxically in studying extra of the context across the occasions that unfolded there, we’re left with much more problems and questions of uncertainty. But when “Future” raised questions of the logistics of those occasions, “Alternative” is a sister episode that raises questions of the motivations and needs of each character concerned in these occasions. That is particularly vital, as a result of the episode additional fractures its views past being both the view of the 4 Jedi on this world or the Brendok coven at giant, and into particular person views all with their very own needs, wants, and ethical views. Among the many Jedi, we see Sol depicted as a uncommon grasp with greater than a touch of want: a craving want to search out himself a padawan, pushed by his perception in responsibility and his want to mentor somebody. We have now Torbin, himself a younger padawan learner, bristling on the considered being dumped on a distant world away from the comforts of his Temple dwelling on Coruscant—”dwelling,” a deliberate phrase he makes use of, one which feels unusual to return out of a Jedi’s mouth—to do busy work within the subject, craving to return to what he is aware of. Indara and Kelnacca are arguably the 2 who’re introduced in the most effective of lights for a lot of the episode, however even they’re compromised by the actions of others: Kelnacca actually, when he’s possessed by the Drive skills of Mom Koril for use as a weapon in opposition to Sol and Torbin once they try to take Osha and Mae by pressure, and Indara extra ethically when it’s in the end her choice, pushed out of a want to guard each Sol and Osha alike, to cowl up the occasions of the evening.

The identical will be stated of the coven, who, whereas not as straight drilled down on right here as the person Jedi are, are nonetheless introduced as a mixture of conflicting views, pushed by likewise related human emotions. On the coronary heart of all of it are the differing views of moms (within the sense of each the mantle because the coven’s management, and because the dad and mom of Osha and Mae) Aniseya and Koril, who each react in several methods to the perceived menace the Jedi symbolize in testing their daughters. This episode frames numerous the coven’s concepts in darkness—in some methods as a result of we see them from Sol’s perspective, strangers with unusual powers who doubtlessly threaten two youngsters to amplify that energy, in others as a result of we see that energy explicitly utilized in aggressive protection in each Aniseya and Koril’s psychological manipulations of Torbin and Kelnacca. However even then, each Aniseya and Koril’s completely different views blur that darkness, not essentially framing the coven as explicitly villainous. Aniseya begins her interactions with the Jedi on a hostile entrance, penetrating Torbin’s thoughts the primary time they arrive knocking, however she additionally in the end advocates in opposition to a lot of her personal sisterhood to make the selection to let the Jedi take Osha, granting her daughter’s want to forge her personal path out of affection. Koril, in the meantime, retains that aggressive stance all through the episode, and is the one who rallies her fellow witches to arms when Sol and Torbin arrive a second time, telling Mae to get offended, and use that anger to defend her household—an anger that in the end leads to Mae inadvertently burning her complete dwelling down. It’s Koril that units the stage for a battle, however it’s Sol and Torbin who actually begin it in igniting their lightsabers—particularly as Sol instantly plunges his into the chest of Aniseya, an nearly instinctual response to her use of the Drive, one that’s by no means made clear to both the characters or the viewers in its intent. All we’re left with is her dying phrases to Sol earlier than all hell breaks free: she was giving him what he needed, letting Osha go away with him, and she or he is repaid along with his judgment, and his concern, leading to her dying, and the seeming deaths of virtually each different witch within the coven, after Koril seemingly makes use of their mixed energy to overwhelm and possess Kelnacca.

But that isn’t essentially essentially the most heinous selection Sol makes by the episode’s finish. It’s essentially the most comprehensible one—a tense scenario, a use of the Drive he doesn’t perceive proper in entrance of him, a snap choice to answer aggression with overwhelming aggression in flip, within the hopes it diffuses the scenario solely. However as we stated, darkness exists in all these characters and their humanity, and it’s his second selection that units the stage for The Acolyte‘s compelling emotional stakes heading into its finale. After the twinfold chaos of the fireplace breaking out and the battle between the Jedi, the witches, and the possessed Kelnacca, it’s revealed to us ultimately that when Sol got here throughout Mae and Osha on a crumbling bridge, it was he who was retaining it up with the Drive: and when he couldn’t stick with it any extra, he determined to let Mae fall to her seeming dying, and save the kid he desired to forge into the coed he at all times needed. Nobody is left untouched by darkness by finish of “Alternative,” however in numerous ways in which darkness was already there after we first met all of those characters, simply manifested in several methods—selfishness, want, attachment, hubris. All human emotions that conflict and intermingle to make the horrors of those occasions unfold in the best way they do.

It’s on this emotionally difficult, clear-yet-unclear second that the stage is about for The Acolyte‘s finale, one brimming with as a lot potential as it’s mired (and made most fascinating) in all this uncertainty. Will or not it’s a grand conflict of Good and Evil, as Star Wars so broadly typically is? Can or not it’s, amid the layers and complexities of the revelations of what really occurred on Brendok, if that fact is in flip revealed to the likes of Osha and Mae? How will the Stranger, or the Jedi Order at giant, issue into this deeply private battle? Even now with the reality revealed to the viewers, there’s solely actually one factor made clear: there are heroes, on either side. However evil—the capability for it, even on this enlightened age of the Excessive Republic—is in every single place.

Need extra io9 information? Try when to count on the newest Marvel, Star Wars, and Star Trek releases, what’s subsequent for the DC Universe on movie and TV, and all the things it’s essential to find out about the way forward for Physician Who.