David Bridges
Legal Battle Escalates: Justin Baldoni Takes on Blake Lively and Marvel
In a dramatic turn of events, social media has intensified the conversation surrounding It Ends With Us director and co-lead Justin Baldoni, who is alleged to have inspired the character “Nicepool” in Deadpool & Wolverine. This controversy has prompted Baldoni’s legal team, headed by renowned attorney Bryan Freedman, to directly address these claims. The spotlight is now shifting towards Blake Lively, who portrays Ladypool in the film, as well as industry giants Kevin Feige of Marvel and Bob Iger of Disney, who are now being drawn into the legal fray.
Reports from Variety indicate that Baldoni’s lawyers are leveraging this situation to issue a litigation hold letter. This document mandates that Disney and Marvel Studios preserve “documents and data” related to Baldoni and the “Nicepool” character, which could be pivotal in the unfolding legal drama.
Throughout the promotional tours for Deadpool & Wolverine and It Ends With Us, tensions between Baldoni and Lively, who starred alongside him in his directorial project, became palpable. The interactions were marked by subtle jabs and creative disagreements that have since escalated. This culminated in Lively filing a lawsuit against Baldoni in December, alleging misconduct on set. In response, Baldoni countersued not just Lively but also the New York Times, asserting that both the actress and the publication misrepresented leaked messages to bolster Lively’s case.
Key moments from Deadpool & Wolverine have come to light, particularly those that resonate with Lively’s allegations against Baldoni. Notably, lines where Nicepool mentions Ladypool “snapping back” into shape after childbirth, followed by the declaration “It’s okay, I identify as a feminist,” have drawn attention. Baldoni has notably promoted his feminist stance on his podcast, which adds layers to this evolving narrative. Additionally, a deleted scene featuring Nicepool referencing a feminist podcast has further fueled speculation, making the “Baldoni is Nicepool?” theory a viral sensation.
The litigation letter from Baldoni’s team specifically requests that Marvel and Disney maintain “any and all documents relating to the development of the ‘Nicepool’ character.” It also seeks to preserve “communications regarding the development, writing, and filming of storylines and scenes featuring ‘Nicepool’,” as well as any documents that may reflect a concerted effort to mock or intimidate Baldoni through this character. According to Variety, the letter was dated January 7, yet, amidst the ongoing turmoil in Los Angeles, there has been little progress as neither party has publicly commented on the case since then.
Are you looking for more updates from io9? Stay informed about the latest Marvel, Star Wars, and Star Trek releases, and discover what’s next for the DC Universe in film and TV, along with everything you need to know about the future of Doctor Who.
Ethan Carter
Brandon Fletcher
