Just a quantity of months suitable following Discovery confirmed how a lot self self-confidence it knowledgeable in taking a Star Trek trope it understood it was superior at and damn close to perfecting it, this week we get the collection diving into another—and not really acquiring considerably interest in why it even took it on in the extremely very first region.

“Filler” has develop to be a soiled term in any dialogue of up to date TV—robbed of its nuance and indicating to fundamentally denote episodes that did not insert Information to the Canon or quickly progress the most vital plot of a show. Filler episodes, at their fairly best, are stories that nonetheless progress the planet of their shows, each by inviting us to take into consideration it from a distinctive viewpoint, or by letting people today to sit with each other beyond the constraints of driving plot to just just be—a prospect to understand challenges that do not topic to the main plot, but problem to developing a sequence really feel loaded, and textured, and persuasive. “Whistlespeak,” the sixth episode of Star Trek: Discovery’s remaining year, then is likely… form of the two?

Subsequent the clue traces thanks to a little help from Kovich—casually beaming Michael into his top rated secret white region hideaway, in which David Cronenberg evidently just craves the really feel of a 21st century notepad—the Discovery finds by itself heading to the planet Halem’no: the web-site of the clue from 1 of the specialists on the employees that hid the Progenitor tech, whose names and species had been specified to Michael by way of Kovich’s notepad. Recognizing that Halem’no is home to each of these a series of rain-making climate towers remaining driving by the scientist at the rear of the crew—and that the planet’s pre-warp inhabitants has collected its culture close to the final operating one—Michael responsibilities herself and Lieutenant Tilly with beaming down, blending in, and acquiring the clue hidden inside just them as promptly as feasible.

Star Trek enjoys a story about skirting the Crucial Directive—the Starfleet mandate that officers just can not, inadvertently or if not, influence a pre-warp civilization by exposing them to technological innovation or the existence of other galactic powers. Discovery’s 32nd century setting is ripe for an consideration-grabbing obtain on one particular distinct, offered that a fantastic deal of the technological friction that existed in preceding sequence that manufactured blending in difficult are now distinctly every a fantastic deal added fraught (everyone can just beam-apparate weapons out of their arms, or pinpoint teleport! It is in essence magic!) and however also so a great deal much less difficult (do not have to sustain a tricorder out now that it is been condensed into a surreptitious get hold of lens). But though “Whistlespeak” is substantial on potentiality—especially when the meat of its struggle is about the force and pull of scientific rationality and non secular faith—it by no means ever definitely coalesces its suggestions into anything that feels remotely fascinating.

Get the titular Whistlespeak for example—a whistle-dependent lexicon applied by the Halem’nites to converse a lot more than prolonged length when shouting their common language would demonstrate difficult. It is a fantastic notion, so considerably so we dedicate a complete scene to Tilly seeing Michael geek out about the anthropological character of it suitable prior to they beam down to the planet, enthusiastic about the parallels it has to their common extended array communication tech: a standard Discovery immediate, acquiring joy in the tactics folks communicate and hook up to just about each other, irrespective of their distance, the idea the present has been routinely unafraid to conquer a lot more than our heads time and time however once again this year. And nonetheless, apart from briefly hearing some when they extremely very first beam down, it beneath no situations comes up—either as a plot machine or a thematic parallel about that believed of speaking across distance—in the episode however once again!

Alternatively, what we get is mostly a non secular retreat crossed with the worst cross nation race you at any time did at university. The spiritual Halem’nites have been congregating to the mountain spire hiding the previous remaining performing temperature tower—which has left Halem’no arid and sparse of rainfall—because they see the spire as a temple to their gods, wherever the most faithful can achieve the correct to suitable petition these larger beings for allow with rainfall. Michael and Tilly, possessing befriended Ravah, the eager-to-prove-by themselves youngster of 1 of the region religious figures, quickly discover that this proof will come in the sort of a mild jog as a outcome of the regional forest developed infinitely even worse by having some form of dehydrating cube at the get began of it, rendering all the folks gasping for air… and, of course, now effortlessly tempted by the bowls of h2o placed about the race course.

If you imagined searching at people today jog by way of a forest when deeply not comfy and dehydrated was commonly not pleasurable to watch, do not get worried: it turns out, it is. But Michael swiftly and conveniently surmises that there will have to be a plot program nearby, noticing that some neighborhood vegetation have been changed in coloration by what she assumes will have to be leaking radiation from the malfunctioning temperature towers. Dropping out of the trial to allow Tilly retain on operating in the hopes at minimum 1 of them aids make it inside the spire, Michael is of course established appropriate about all this—and that the final tower failing will lead to just about each Halem’nite perishing anyway—because it is considerably far a lot more fascinating to observe a Star Trek character resolve a tech aid puzzle than it is observing them uncomfortably fifty %-operate.

The damaging news receives worse for Tilly when every she and Ravah handle to complete the demo, earning them the proper to complete the spire… and be ritually sacrificed by implies of asphyxiation to bring forth rain. Womp womp! It is listed right here the ethical dilemma at the crux of “Whistlespeak” ought to really go into overdrive—is Discovery’s mission to uncover the clues to the Progenitors so very important that it can override the important principle of Starfleet? What is dropped when this technological improvement is uncovered to a deeply religious people today right now who have found that implies more than and above it? At what level does the compassion and figuring out questioned of Starfleet officers wrestle with the scientific reasoning and logic that guides their obligation in the extremely very first place?

Alternatively, the episode just form of shrugs and, actually as a outcome of Michael, decides it’ll fill out the paperwork later. And in undertaking so, any of the type of tension that was driven by the possible danger Tilly and Ravah had been getting in is just instantaneously undercut. Michael beams in correct in front of Ravah’s father, who was nonetheless in the spire looking for to comfort his dying kid from afar, and points out that she’s fundamentally an alien with know-how akin to the power of the gods them selves, and that she can right all the towers and make it so no a great deal a lot more people today have to be sacrificed. Bizarrely, he counter argues that perhaps they require to preserve killing people today right now in any case, mostly simply because it is got a sort of neighborhood spirit vibe that brings persons collectively, but at this level each of these Michael and the episode by itself have run out of time to dig into all that, so they just range of sidestep it. And with that, the day is saved, the clue is observed (not even in the important spire that was central to the complete episode!), and totally absolutely everyone goes off on their merry way. Eeeeeeh.

Glibness aside, it is not like there are not fascinating ideas in “Whistlespeak”—Star Trek has a extremely extended history of attempting to tackle what non secular religion appears like in its sophisticated societies, and how it sits along with the science-driven reasoning that defines so pretty a handful of of its heroes. But “Whistlespeak” by no means ever feels in particular interested itself into diving into these thoughts, in a immediate exactly where the practical experience-pushed vibes of this final time definitely definitely do not operate out in its favors. The show tries to hyperlink it all back once again to the characters on Discovery itself—mostly in a subplot with Dr. Culber, nonetheless stuck on his quasi-non secular functioning practical experience on Trill, and attempting to make feeling of that as the two a man of medication and science and a companion who is also decidedly non-spiritual—but contemplating we’re at the very close of this recap and I have only just regarded as to provide it up, that need to inform you how especially trenchant that hyperlink managed to be (the subplot finishes, fundamentally, with E book telling Culber that at occasions it is just all suitable to sense a issue for your self, in its location of sharing it with other folks in your existence, and which is that. Thanks Guide!).

The overarching plot of the year is inched forward here—our heroes have the penultimate clue, and have an notion of exactly where by to head for the next—but “Whistlespeak” just does not make fantastic use of the time that is now swiftly operating out for Discovery to place its ducks in a row in advance of just one particular extremely final sendoff. We’re in a operate of episodes this final season that, though mainly nevertheless repeating themes and tactics Discovery has currently had a issue to say about, nonetheless situated tactics to articulate these themes and ideas, unsubtly or generally, in pleasing strategies. “Whistlespeak” feels like further of a shrug alongside the way in comparison, but with it in reality now out of that way, ideally Discovery can get back once again to far a lot more fascinating variables as this race attracts to its conclusion.

Star Trek: Discovery is out there to stream now on Paramount+.

Want a lot more io9 info? Test out when to be expecting the most up-to-date Marvel, Star Wars, and Star Trek releases, what is subsequent for the DC Universe on film and Television set, and each issue you have to have to know about the extended run of Doctor Who.