Physician Who, like all science fiction, has at all times rooted its storytelling in allegory—elevating concepts to problem its up to date viewers via tales of the previous, the longer term, of monsters, and working down hallways. It at all times makes the moments the present desires to step away from an allegorical message and explicitly talk about a societal agenda tough to navigate: what may be left to viewers interpretation, what must be made clear, what’s the second to make your break and be express about your message?

“Dot and Bubble” is an episode that thinks about this so much—however whether or not it’s an episode that actually succeeds in successfully conveying its actual message makes for what is likely one of the most troublesome episodes to speak in regards to the collection has completed in a really very long time.

So why is “Dot and Bubble” so troublesome to debate? It’s an episode that’s, ostensibly, about one allegory—the affect of social media on our lives, filtered via a society of futuristic Not-TikTok (the title is actually the system/platform, a holographic bubble that tasks a hemisphere of social media screens round a person’s head) influencers in a seemingly idyllic group known as Finetime. However what the episode really is, like “73 Yards” was earlier than it, is a thriller field, structured round a final-scene reveal that radically realigns the remainder of the episode you’ve simply been served for 40 minutes.

What you’re served, on the floor, is a maybe effectively which means, however clunky warning in regards to the perils of social media utilization. “Dot and Bubble” largely follows the story of Lindy Pepper-Bean (Callie Cooke, a visitor star in a task that, as we’ll get into, turns into extremely fraught), one in every of Finetime’s ditzy inhabitants. Endlessly scrolling via video feeds of her buddies from the second she will get up, Lindy is a strolling, speaking embodiment of the more severe form of assumptions individuals make about chronically on-line social media addicts—airheaded, impolite, younger, and inexperienced with the fact of the world past her metaphorical and literal bubble. All her display screen buddies are the identical: loud, garish, petulantly ignorant, and annoying, and all Lindy does is natter again at them from her personal display screen, complaining how arduous it’s that they must work doing senseless information inputting for 2 hours a day earlier than they’ll get again to endlessly scrolling via movies of vapid particular person after vapid particular person, regurgitating limitless, empty content material again at one another.

So when it seems that Finetime is definitely being attacked by a military of large alien slugs—choosing off one resident after the following, devouring them as a result of they’re so managed and hooked on their Dot and Bubbles they’ll’t see the menace staring them within the face till it’s consuming them alive—Lindy, on the behest of the Physician and Ruby digitally sliding into her social feed to warn her of the menace to her life, turns into our more and more unlikeable protagonist. Barely stumbling her approach via our precise heroes’ recommendation, she tries to flee the large slugs that, push involves shove, you finally start to really feel like ought to really get to eat her. In the meantime, the Physician and Ruby attempt to determine simply how Finetime has become a Big Slug Buffet. And if this was what “Dot and Bubble” was really about, it could maybe be tremendous, if a bit of rote—a heavy handed admonishment of the youngsters nowadays with their apps and their viral movies, however one which performs with Physician Who’s messages of empathy and understanding to have us, and the Physician and Ruby, help a distinctly unlikable protagonist as they face sure doom. Perhaps there’s a model of “Dot and Bubble” the place Lindy learns to the touch grass or use social media for good as an alternative of simply limitless sycophancy, and the day is saved, and all of us transfer on to the following journey.

However “Dot and Bubble” isn’t that episode in any respect. In its closing moments—after Lindy has managed to outlive and make her approach out of Finetime, after cruelly and casually sacrificing a fellow resident and her social media idol, faux-internet movie star Ricky September (Tom Rhys Harries)—the episode reveals its precise intent and the character of Finetime’s society. Now that she’s lastly met the Physician and Ruby exterior of her Bubble’s feed, Lindy and her fellow survivors are provided a secure approach off world on the TARDIS—however they reject the Physician, selecting to transcend Finetime’s protecting shielding and try to adapt to the wild on their very own, as a result of the Physician is a Black man. “You, sir, are not one of us,” Lindy spits at him, admonishing the Physician for daring to make in-person contact along with her. One other survivor tells her to step again from him, lest they be “contaminated.” Finetime’s society isn’t just a social media-driven nightmare, it seems, it’s a white supremacist, colonial construction, dropped down onto an alien world by its presumably equally racist dwelling civilization to create what it envisions as mono-race haven for younger, wealthy, white individuals who consider they’ve a god-given proper to do no matter they need due to their race.

Within the second, it’s horrifying and hits you want a ton of bricks. Ncuti Gatwa delivers an unimaginable, tortured efficiency in only a single, temporary scene, howling at first in baffled confusion, after which rage, that Finetime’s survivors are so catastrophically bigoted they’d select sure loss of life over being saved by a Black particular person. The episode ends on this second of readability, as Lindy and her racist buddies go off in a single course, and the Physician and Ruby, in tears, stroll again in the direction of the TARDIS. However for as successfully jarring as it’s as a twist, this one single, closing scene—a handful of minutes’ runtime on the very finish of the episode—it’s additionally a second that takes an extremely critical message, and fumbles making it as a result of as an alternative of it being the dramatic crux of the episode, it’s precisely that: a last-minute twist.

Treating the existence of white supremacy as a “gotcha” on this method is an extremely fraught concept, and it’s a subject that must be greater than a revelation within the closing minutes of an episode if Physician Who is definitely going to sort out it as a direct concept, moderately than via layers of allegory. “Dot and Bubble” is structured in such a approach that it could possibly by no means try this, and help the chew of its closing scene. Lindy is a caricature of an unlikable character even earlier than simply how vile she is turns into express within the closing scene, however “Dot and Bubble” nonetheless asks you to root for her for the overwhelming majority of its episode—even at what initially seems to be the depths of her egocentric cruelty when she intentionally will get Ricky killed so she will be able to escape—as a result of the overwhelming majority of the episode is just not actually straight about Finetime being “Planet of the Racist TikTokers,” and Physician Who is a TV collection that makes asking us to be empathetic with out judgment one in every of its key values. Even when the character is, on the floor, extraordinarily annoying as Lindy seems to be, Physician Who desires us to have empathy for its focal views, as a result of that’s what the Physician would do. You may’t simply take that concept, after which twist it by going “Whoops, it was a racist all alongside!”

You may’t ever watch “Dot and Bubble” once more for the primary time. You may’t watch any thriller or plot-twist pushed narrative once more the best way you probably did for the primary time—each viewing after that’s basically altered by your information of regardless of the thriller or reveal really is. Each additional engagement with the textual content after that turns into about with the ability to look at and establish clues with in its construction, to see how successfully that reveal is constructed in the direction of. “Dot and Bubble” isn’t any exception to this, however it’s each an episode that’s fully, radically reformed on re-watch by the information the ultimate scene lays out, and in addition one which has its essential flaws uncovered in doing so. In being arrange in service of a thriller with a last-minute twist, all the things in regards to the episode’s precise supposed allegory—the evils of white supremacy in our society and in on-line areas, not simply the concept that children on social media are rotting their brains for non-racist causes—is left as much as the broad interpretation of what’s doubtless a majority-white viewers.

There are certainly loads of “clues” all through “Dot and Bubble” that click on into place with the ultimate reveal. It’s there in Lindy’s ceaseless annoyance every time the Physician tries to assist her, however can grin and bear it when it’s Ruby that tells her what to do to flee the slugs as an alternative. It’s there, too, within the background realization you make that everybody on the screens in Lindy’s bubble, everybody strolling round Finetime, each glimpse we get of its administration, is a white face—that the Physician is the one particular person of shade in the complete episode. That final level, particularly, is the authorial intent that author Russell T Davies hangs the episode’s “thriller” on. “What we are able to’t inform is how many individuals can have labored that out earlier than the ending,” Davies notes in an interview for Physician Who Unleashed, the BBC’s behind-the-scenes help collection launched after every episode of the collection, “as a result of they’ve seen white particular person after white particular person after white particular person [in the episode]… I ponder, will you be 10 minutes into it? Will you be 15? Will you be 20, earlier than you begin to suppose ‘everybody on this group is white,’ and for those who don’t suppose that, why didn’t you?”

However leaving that realization as much as the idea of a predominantly white viewers to resolve as a clue, moderately than making it one thing explicitly addressed and engaged with by the narrative of the episode earlier than its closing scene, is just not solely a particularly neoliberal method to dealing with the subject of white supremacy—that recognizing that it exists is the factor that ought to be rewarded, as an alternative of truly saying or doing one thing about it, particularly within the context of a collection like Physician Who, which has a 60-year report of predominantly casting white individuals in main and supporting roles—it additionally weakens what the episode itself can say in regards to the evils of this ideology. The construction of the episode is designed as such is that the intent is you’re preserving the reveal that Finetime is a bigoted enclave a secret till the ultimate minutes of the episode. This can be a battle that the present season of Physician Who has confronted a number of instances already—that its episodes depart, deliberately or in any other case, gaps in logic or exposition to ask of its viewers their very own interpretation for why one thing is the best way it’s within the story, for higher or worse. That’s one thing you are able to do with, say, how the supernatural talents of “73 Yards” and its time loop paradox works, or the pc logic that results in the creation of the Boogeyman creature in “Area Infants.” It’s not one thing that ought to be completed when what you need to ask the viewers to interpret is the existence of white supremacy and its horrors: that’s one thing you have to reckon with clearly within the textual content itself.

So let’s come again to that closing scene with the Physician and Lindy then, and look at how “Dot and Bubble” really approaches being a narrative in regards to the evils of white supremacy as its ending reveals. Isolating its option to be express till its closing minutes—and leaving each trace that Finetime is a racist society as much as the viewers divining it as a clue earlier than the reveal—implies that, structurally, “Dot and Bubble” can by no means give the Physician an opportunity to be conscious of, and even deal with, the repeated microaggressions and discrimination he faces looking for out what’s occurring in Finetime, till he’s explicitly advised to his face that the explanation Lindy and the survivors don’t need his assistance is as a result of he’s Black. He’s by no means given an opportunity to be annoyed about the truth that Lindy and the opposite Bubble customers gained’t take heed to him, at the same time as he’s attempting to assist them keep away from being devoured alive, however will take heed to Ruby—each second of frustration alongside the best way that he feels must be made obscure sufficient that it seems to be like he’s simply aggravated that Lindy is unlikable and egocentric, and for thus many different causes, as a result of the episode is structurally treating her bigotry as a secret to be revealed later. “Dot and Bubble” desires its viewers to interrogate the world of Finetime, and see how lengthy it takes them to note its structural racism, which implies the Physician himself isn’t allowed to touch upon it alongside the best way.

For all of the clues to choose up alongside the best way, “Dot and Bubble” is just not structured to permit itself to be “The Episode The place the Physician Experiences White Supremacy as a Black Individual” till its closing scene—and in a scene that’s a handful of minutes lengthy, that’s nowhere close to sufficient time to unpack what the episode might intend to say about what it implies that the Physician, who, for the overwhelming majority of the collection’ historical past, has been capable of barge into any room and get what he desires from full strangers as a result of he’s within the type of a heteronormative white man, to be confronted with a situation the place his bodily type of a special minority background. There’s maybe a comparability right here to “The Witchfinders,” the uncommon episode of Jodie Whittaker’s run on Physician Who that engages with the truth that the Physician is presenting as feminine throughout its narrative. Was it episode? Not actually, however on the very least it allowed the Physician to comprehend that she was being discriminated towards due to sexist ideology, and made it the crux of its dramatic battle, as a result of it allowed that second of battle to be revealed sooner than the ultimate minutes of the episode.

Physician Who can and will use the meta-narrative of it breaking boundaries with various casting to, inside its textual content, touch upon actual world problems with prejudice and discrimination that may be confronted by making these casting decisions: casting feminine Medical doctors, casting non-white Medical doctors, casting queer Medical doctors, and so forth. Not solely is that an essential agenda for a collection that’s a few hero who prides themselves on empathy and understanding of the huge universe round them, it additionally opens Physician Who as much as extra storytelling alternatives, to inform extra tales about extra sorts of people who have, traditionally up up to now, not been represented by having the Physician’s default type from one incarnation to the opposite be that of a white man, and even have individuals from these backgrounds inform these tales, too. However once you select to take action, you additionally must reckon with the query of what it means to not simply be treating the Physician as “the Physician” in that form of story, but in addition explicitly treating them as an individual current within the physique of a minority, and analyzing that minorities’ struggles in the true world—and what you then ask of the viewers represented on display screen to look at of these struggles in flip.

That in and of itself turns into a difficulty within the closing scene of “Dot and Bubble”, as a result of a part of the purpose of the Physician’s anguished horror when Lindy and the opposite survivors reject his assistance is that his empathy—he virtually begs them to let him save them from sure doom—doesn’t work. The Physician is allowed to be shocked on the revelation of Finetime’s white supremacist underpinnings, however his final response is just not about white supremacy’s existence on this society, however the grief that he can’t overcome that hateful ideology and save the individuals beholden to that ideology. Like we mentioned, Physician Who is a collection about empathy—however on this second the Physician, within the physique of a Black man, is requested to empathize for individuals who hate his very existence due to his pores and skin shade. The Physician isn’t allowed to inform Lindy and her racist buddies to fuck off and get eaten by large slugs, for all he cares, as a result of he’s the Physician. He has to care about saving individuals, even when they’re blinded to his assist by their horrifyingly evil beliefs.

That’s an extremely fraught message for Physician Who to must try to convey to its viewers—both the assumptive broader white viewers it has left clues for all through “Dot and Bubble,” or the viewers of individuals of shade watching and seeing themselves in Ncuti Gatwa’s Physician. And even then, on this closing second, with “Dot and Bubble” and its intention to go away a lot of it open to the interpretation of its viewers, we by no means get to see Lindy and the opposite survivors face comeuppance for his or her racism. The episode ends with the publicity of white supremacy’s existence, after which can’t say or do something extra past that, as a result of it’s saved that publicity for a handful of minutes earlier than the tip credit. Positive, it may be implied that after the credit roll, Lindy and her bigoted buddies get into a ship to sail off into the wilds past Finetime and instantly die excruciating deaths, as a result of they’re silly bigots who’ve spent their complete lives as much as that time residing within the bubble of faux-TikTok, however the episode by no means really tells us that that’s the case. It could actually by no means make the express bounce that these individuals will face hubristic loss of life for his or her racism, as a result of it chooses to finish on them crusing away and the Physician leaving in tears. If something, by leaving a lot of the supposed message of “Dot and Bubble” as much as the viewers to divine and interpret themselves, you make sufficient house for a few of that viewers to imagine that Lindy and the others go on to outlive and even thrive past Finetime’s boarders. In spite of everything, for a lot of the episode we see Lindy realized and adapt lengthy sufficient to flee the slugs—there are as many clues that she might survive as there are clues to Finetime’s supremacist racial construction!

I’m certain a collection as progressively minded as Physician Who doesn’t need any a part of its viewers to have an opportunity of considering “effectively, did the racists come out okay, really.” However for those who don’t need that to be your message, you must be crystal clear about your message, even when it’s one which on the floor is so simple as “white supremacy exists and is unhealthy.” “Dot and Bubble” falters as a result of it’s structurally unequipped to be clear about that message till its closing scene—and the purpose is that it’s unclear about this, as a result of its intent is to keep up the facet of its twist ending for almost all of its viewers. And even then, there’s is simply not sufficient time for it to unpack and talk about the extremely actual matter it hopes to put out to that viewers. There’s a model of “Dot and Bubble” that brings its racial allegory into the sunshine a lot earlier, and far more explicitly, and makes it the crux of its story moderately than the thriller of simply what is occurring in Finetime within the first place—and in flip, has the time to be far more full throated in regards to the evils of white supremacy, as an alternative of merely acknowledging that it nonetheless exists. Perhaps that’s, even, a narrative advised by a author of shade, too.

However we’re left to surprise all that, and what that episode may need been, for good or ailing. As a result of no matter it may need ended up being, it was most definitely not the episode we finally acquired.

Need extra io9 information? Take a look at when to count on the newest Marvel, Star Wars, and Star Trek releases, what’s subsequent for the DC Universe on movie and TV, and all the things that you must learn about the way forward for Physician Who.