SNL Hosts Who Committed Murder: John Mulaney’s Joke Unpacked

SNL50: The Anniversary Special delivered a plethora of laughs to commemorate Saturday Night Live‘s monumental 50th birthday celebration, but one particular joke from John Mulaney caught the audience’s attention and left many wondering. Mulaney humorously alluded to the notion of past SNL hosts who allegedly committed murder, raising eyebrows and sparking curiosity among fans. As a result, viewers are eager to uncover whether there is any kernel of truth behind that intriguing jest.

During the anniversary special aired on February 16, 2025, Mulaney humorously remarked, “As I look around, I see some of the most difficult people I have ever met in my entire life.” He continued with a tongue-in-cheek comment about the impressive roster of SNL hosts, stating, “Over the course of 50 years, 894 people have hosted Saturday Night Live, and it amazes me that only two of them have committed murder.” This joke not only entertained but also piqued the interest of fans who are now investigating the implications behind Mulaney’s words.

Curious to know more? Discover below who Mulaney might have been referencing during his monologue and whether any former SNL hosts have indeed been involved in murder cases. These revelations could shed light on the dark humor behind Mulaney’s joke and provide an insightful look into the lives of those who have graced the SNL stage.

How to Watch SNL50 Online: Streaming Options

All fans eager to relive the nostalgic moments of SNL50 can easily stream the special events, including the exhilarating Homecoming Concert and the remarkable 50th Anniversary Special, exclusively on Peacock. These exciting events were not only broadcast live on NBC but also made available for streaming on Peacock throughout the weekend of February 14 to February 16, 2025. This accessibility allows fans to enjoy the rich history and comedic brilliance that Saturday Night Live has showcased over the decades.

Did the Notorious O.J. Simpson Ever Host SNL?

Indeed, O.J. Simpson made his mark as a host on SNL back in 1978, long before the infamous events surrounding his ex-wife, Nicole Brown, and her friend Ron Goldman, who tragically lost their lives in a brutal stabbing incident in 1994. This historical hosting raises questions about the intersection of entertainment and crime, making it a significant talking point among fans and critics alike.

Exploring the Dark Side: Which SNL Hosts Have Been Involved in Murder Cases?

While no former SNL hosts have been definitively proven guilty of murder beyond a reasonable doubt, it is widely believed that Mulaney’s humorous references in his SNL50 monologue were likely aimed at O.J. Simpson and Robert Blake. Both of these individuals faced serious charges in murder cases but were ultimately acquitted. This intriguing connection between comedy and crime adds an unexpected layer to the legacy of Saturday Night Live.

In 1994, O.J. Simpson was charged with the devastating murders of Brown and Goldman, but he was acquitted in a highly publicized trial that captured the nation’s attention in 1995. Despite his acquittal, Simpson later faced a civil lawsuit where he was found liable for the wrongful death of Goldman and the battery of Brown, resulting in a staggering $33.5 million damages awarded against him. His controversial life came to an end in 2024 when he passed away at the age of 76, yet his story remains a topic of discussion and intrigue.

Similarly, Robert Blake, who hosted SNL in 1982, was embroiled in a murder case following the tragic death of his second wife, Bonny Lee Bakley, in 2001. Bakley was shot while sitting in Blake’s car, and he was allegedly inside a nearby restaurant at the time of the incident. Blake consistently maintained that he had no involvement in her murder, which led to a sensational trial.

Blake was acquitted of the murder charges in 2005; however, he was later found liable for wrongful death in a civil lawsuit, resulting in a $30 million judgment against him. Despite the acquittal, the shadow of the case loomed large over his life, and Blake passed away in 2023 at the age of 89, leaving behind a complicated legacy intertwined with both fame and controversy.