Whenever a murder investigation captures public attention, it often triggers a wave of related media, including movies, documentaries, and television shows, typically in development shortly after. In recent years, true crime has emerged as a dominant theme in Hollywood, with the infamous Gilgo Beach murders taking center stage. This tragic case, steeped in decades of mystery, has inspired various media interpretations, from gripping television specials produced by networks like Lifetime to in-depth docuseries and feature films. These creative projects delve into a case that was long considered cold, breathing new life into the stories of the victims and the ongoing quest for justice.
Explore below the array of compelling movies, enlightening documentaries, and captivating TV shows that draw inspiration from the chilling Gilgo Beach murders.
Exploring the Untitled Netflix Docuseries on Gilgo Beach Murders
In the works is an untitled Netflix docuseries that aims to shed light on the intricate investigation and subsequent arrest of Rex Heuermann in 2023. The series is directed by the acclaimed Liz Garbus, who stated, “With the arrest of suspect Rex Heuermann on July 13 of this year, a new chapter began in the decades-old investigation of the missing and murdered women found in Gilgo Beach and beyond. And yet, just as some questions start being answered, new ones emerge.” This statement underscores the complexity and evolving nature of this high-profile case, promising viewers a deep dive into the ongoing investigative saga.
A specific release date for this highly anticipated docuseries has yet to be announced, leaving audiences eager for updates on its debut.
Watch the Gripping Drama Lost Girls on Netflix

The powerful 2020 film Lost Girls draws direct inspiration from the unresolved Gilgo Beach case and features a talented cast, including Amy Ryan, Gabriel Byrne, and Thomasin McKenzie. This emotional drama intricately weaves the narrative of a mother’s desperate search for her missing daughter, highlighting the profound impact of unresolved cases on families.
According to Netflix, the film’s synopsis reads, “Desperate to find her missing daughter, a mother fights to uncover the truth — and helps expose a string of unsolved murders.” This gripping storyline encapsulates the tension and urgency surrounding the search for answers in a complex and tragic situation.
Discover The Long Island Serial Killer: A Mother’s Hunt for Justice on Lifetime
Lifetime’s film, based on real events, stars Kim Delaney and Katharine Isabelle, focusing on “Mari Gilbert’s search for the truth behind what happened to her daughter Shannan, a sometime escort who disappeared after a ‘date’ on Long Island.” This narrative brings to light the personal anguish and relentless pursuit of justice faced by families of victims in cases like these.
“After Shannan fails to come home, her mother Mari knows something is terribly wrong,” the synopsis for the Lifetime movie reveals. “Pleading to police to take her concerns seriously, she keeps pushing the police for answers. Mari’s insistence that her daughter not be overlooked eventually leads to a horror hidden on Long Island for more than a decade – 19 bodies of young women discovered buried in shallow graves along Ocean Parkway in the area of Jones Beach State Park. Though the search for the killer is still ongoing, Mari’s passionate dedication to giving her daughter and other forgotten women a voice, and the attention they deserve, has kept the case alive with hopes of a breakthrough soon.” This poignant story underscores the challenges faced by families in the quest for justice and recognition in a complex legal landscape.









