Australia’s impartial regulator for on the web protection has ended its bid to clear away a violent video clip from X (formerly Twitter).

On April 15, a clergyman was stabbed in Sydney, Australia, and, like some other horrific incidents these instances, it was broadcast on the internet. Australia’s nationwide regulator, eSafety, asked for that all social media platforms just take down the video clip. While eSafety claims Meta, Google, TikTok and further eradicated it, X only stopped Australian viewers from accessing the film — something a VPN can conveniently circumvent. When eSafety pushed for it to be totally taken down, X’s CEO Elon Musk known as the request an assault on price-no cost speech and argued that a single unique country’s laws could not handle the whole globe, The Register reported.

Even with dropping the combat in opposition to X, eSafety further reiterated their frustrations. “Our sole objective and emphasis in issuing our removal find out was to avert this exceptionally violent footage from probably viral, potentially inciting additional violence and inflicting further hurt on the Australian neighborhood neighborhood,” Julie Inman Grant, the commissioner of eSafety, stated. “Most Australians settle for this kind of graphic content material actually must not be on broadcast television, which begs an apparent concern of why it will need to be permitted to be dispersed freely and accessible on-line 24/7 to any individual, like tiny ones.”

Grant notes that X did obtain down a video globally that compiled this assault with two other stabbing incidents. She also particulars the violence coverage X laid out to the European Commission preceding October as proof that the platform will need to take away the video totally. “…our firm has clear policies that prohibit violent and hateful entities, perpetrators of violent attacks, violent speech, delicate media and the synthetic and manipulated media program,” the passage states. “For the avoidance of doubt, we strictly adhere to our policies relating to illegal content material and we go on to take away unlawful content material, which contains terrorist content material material, from our platform.” In that vein, she telephone calls obtaining down the on the web video a “fair request” for X to obtain.