Series Insights: Everything We Know – Hollywood Life

View gallery

The suspense from Acorn TV’s latest mystery series is killing us in the best way! Starring Brooke Shields and Amalia Williamson, the buzz surrounding You’re Killing Me has just begun. However, as with any TV show filled with high stakes, a little competition, and a touch of murder, the appetite for a second season will only grow from here. So, is there a season 2 of You’re Killing Me?

Hollywood Life provides the latest updates on the future of You’re Killing Me, along with everything you need to know about its debut season below.

What Is the Plot of You’re Killing Me?

The Acorn TV series follows novelist Allie (played by Brooke Shields) and her unlikely ally, podcaster and aspiring writer Andi (played by Amalia Williamson), as they navigate a quaint New England town where murder and mystery unfold right in front of them. This intriguing premise sets the stage for a thrilling experience.

The hilariously toxic dynamic between Allie and Andi serves as a central theme of the show, which Brooke Shields discussed exclusively with Hollywood Life at the red carpet premiere in New York City, shedding light on the depth of their relationship.

“Well, the butting of the heads was what made it really interesting because you’ve got two generations, very different, and they can learn from each other,” Shields emphasized. “She makes fun of me, I make fun of her, and it’s in that that the dialogue starts, and it’s funny, you know what I mean? It’s funny to not take those differences so seriously, but actually learn from each other.”

Meanwhile, for Williamson, the Letterkenny alum noted that her and Shields’ characters “need each other to be successful in all areas of life,” regardless of their generational differences, highlighting the importance of their relationship.

“I think she has a really hard time at first, just in terms of their generational differences,” Williamson revealed exclusively to Hollywood Life. “Her mom left when she was so young, so I think, at first, she finds Allie’s character really, really annoying, but then realizes she’s kind of exactly what Andi needs in terms of her career, romantic relationships, and even a motherly figure.”

How Many Episodes Are There in Season 1 of You’re Killing Me?

The first season of You’re Killing Me consists of six episodes, each filled with suspense and engaging storylines that keep viewers on the edge of their seats.

Is There a Season 2 of You’re Killing Me Planned?

As of the time of publication, Acorn TV has not yet renewed You’re Killing Me for a second season, leaving fans eagerly awaiting updates.

Hollywood Life had the opportunity to speak with showrunner and creator Robin Bernheim during the season 1 premiere. She expressed that they are “definitely … hoping for a second season,” indicating a positive outlook for the show’s future.

“There’s some stuff about how my generation relates to things like AI and how the younger generation interacts with [it],” Bernheim explained while discussing the potential for the show to extend beyond its first season.

How to Stream New Episodes of You’re Killing Me?

All new episodes of You’re Killing Me will be available for streaming on Acorn TV starting on May 18, 2026, allowing fans to dive deeper into the thrilling narratives.